What Business Owners Use a Valuation For, and Where Our Report From $799 Fits
Our FAQ describes a business valuation as a process to find out how much your business is worth, for purposes such as selling a company, tax compliance, litigation, strategic planning or negotiating with investors. Our indicative valuation, from $799, is meant for internal use; the FAQ recommends it when the valuation does not need to be reviewed by an external party, “i.e. the IRS or in litigation”. Below are the uses the case studies on this site describe, the official rules where the IRS or a lender is involved, and where the indicative valuation fits.
The purpose and the date of a valuation
One case study on this site describes an industrial equipment distributor that was valued twice. The first valuation was for gift and estate planning; the second was to assess potential negotiations with prospective buyers. It was the same company, but the case study says the different purposes and valuation dates led to substantially different results.
The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.4) are written for IRS staff who value businesses or review valuations prepared by others. They have the appraiser define each assignment by identifying, among other things, the interest to be valued, the effective valuation date, and the purpose and use of the valuation.
Revenue Ruling 59-60 is the IRS’s ruling on valuing shares of closely held corporations, those whose shares are owned by a relatively limited number of stockholders, for estate and gift tax. It says valuing such shares must be based on the facts available at the required date of appraisal. The IRS publishes the ruling’s text as an appendix to a job aid for its valuation analysts.
So before you rely on an earlier valuation for something new, check that it was made for the same purpose and for a date that still fits.
Preparing a sale or an investment
In another case study, the owner of a digital advertising agency founded in 2019 wanted a valuation for internal planning and to prepare for a potential transaction with outside investors. The aims were insight into the agency’s current value for strategic decisions, and a valuation to present to potential investors. The client received a summary valuation report that included a valuation range.
That report also highlighted areas for improvement before a sale. The valuation had faced two main challenges:
- The accounts paired high revenue with equally high direct costs, leaving low gross profit. The case study says this way of accounting was misaligned with industry practices, hindering comparability.
- There was no formal growth plan, which made future earnings difficult to project.
The report recommended improving the agency’s financial reporting practices and developing a formal growth plan. The stated aim of these recommendations was to enhance future valuations and the agency’s appeal to investors. The case study does not say whether the recommendations were carried out, or whether a transaction followed.
The distributor returned for its second valuation to assess potential negotiations with prospective buyers. The case study says the methodology used for it focused on market dynamics, private equity (PE) practices and value drivers specific to the machinery distribution industry. It says the analysis gave the client insights for informed decision-making and strategic positioning in negotiations. It does not say whether negotiations took place or whether the business was sold.
If a buyer will pay with an SBA 7(a) loan, the SBA’s Standard Operating Procedure 50 10 (version 8.1, effective October 1, 2026) says the business valuation must be requested by and prepared for the lender. The lender may not use one prepared for the applicant or the seller. So a valuation you order as the seller cannot be the one the lender uses.
The lender’s valuation must support the business purchase price: the price in the purchase agreement, less any owner-occupied commercial real estate bought in the same deal. If the amount paid for the business is more than the valuation, the difference must be made up by equity. Our article on business valuation requirements for SBA 7(a) loans covers the rest of these rules.
Gifts, estate planning and succession
At the time of the distributor’s first valuation, its owner was approaching retirement. The company aimed to optimize its tax liability through the valuation of an equity interest in the business to be gifted. Revenue Ruling 59-60 explains that property in a deceased person’s gross estate, or made the subject of a gift, is taxed on its value at a set date. That date is the time of death (or an alternate date, if elected) or the date of the gift.
If the business depends on you, that counts in such a valuation. The ruling says the loss of the manager of a so-called “one-man” business may have a depressing effect on the value of its stock. That is particularly so if there is a lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to the management.
The ruling treats the effect of losing the manager, and the absence of anyone able to succeed to the management, as factors to be taken into consideration. They are weighed against offsetting factors, such as life insurance that adequately covers the loss.
The SBA’s 7(a) rules list an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) or equivalent trust buying a controlling interest (51% or more) in the business as a type of change of ownership. Under 26 U.S.C. § 401(a)(28), an ESOP’s trust is not a qualified trust unless, among other requirements, certain valuations are by an independent appraiser. The valuations covered are all valuations of employer securities not readily tradable on an established securities market, with respect to activities carried on by the plan.
Tax filings: donations, conversions and stock options
A third case study describes three special purpose vehicles (SPVs) whose balance sheets held only cash. They donated an ownership interest that would let their owners gain a tax advantage. The owners needed what the case study calls a “certified valuation” to fill in the necessary IRS forms. The case study says they were able to apply for their tax advantages; it does not say the advantages were granted.
In a fourth, the owner of a pre-revenue e-commerce venture needed a valuation of a 20% membership interest held by the venture’s incubator. The incubator was converting to a limited liability company (LLC) and required the assets to be valued for tax purposes. Neither of these two case studies names the tax rule or the forms involved.
If you donate property, such as an interest in your business, and claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for it, IRS Publication 561 says you generally must get a qualified appraisal. It must be signed and dated by a qualified appraiser, and you must attach Form 8283 to your tax return. The publication also says the IRS is responsible for reviewing appraisals and does not accept them without question.
If your company grants stock options, the section 409A regulations look at the exercise price. One condition for a nonstatutory stock option not to provide for a deferral of compensation is that its exercise price can never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock on the date the option is granted. Our article on business valuation costs and when you need more sets out the rules for charitable deductions, gifts to family and stock options in more detail.
Where our indicative valuation fits
Our shop lists the Indicative Valuation for “Internal Purposes – e.g. Strategic or Exit Planning”. Services & Pricing adds “identifying a reasonable transaction price to negotiate”. The FAQ says the indicative valuation is not as detailed as a full valuation and does not come with a detailed valuation report.
A valuation behind a charitable deduction is open to IRS review, so it falls outside the case the FAQ recommends the indicative valuation for. For an SBA 7(a) loan to buy a business, no report you order can be the lender’s valuation (see above). Our free calculator is designed for educational purposes and early-stage planning, and its results are not certified appraisals.
Related reading
- Business Valuation Costs: Reports From $799, and When You Need More
- Case Study: Valuing Three Cash-Only Companies for IRS Forms Tied to a Tax Advantage
- Case Study: Valuing an Equipment Distributor for Gift Planning, Then for Potential Talks With Buyers
Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.