Automated Business Valuation: What Our Free Calculator Can and Cannot Tell You

Our free business valuation calculator turns a few figures you type in into an estimate, using one of four methods that you choose. It works only from those figures, and the method, the rates and the figures themselves are left to you. We say its results are not certified appraisals. This page sets out what the calculator does, what it leaves out, and what IRS guidance says a valuation involves beyond a formula.

What the calculator does

You choose a method with one of four buttons, and the calculator shows that method’s result on its own. Each method uses only the figures in its own fields:

  • DCF Method starts from your annual cash flow for year 1 and grows it each later year at your growth rate, for the number of years you set. It discounts each year’s cash flow at your discount rate and adds the results. Ticking “Include Terminal Value” adds a terminal value, worked out from the last year’s cash flow, a terminal growth rate you enter and the discount rate.
  • Multiple Based multiplies the annual earnings you enter by the multiple you enter.
  • Asset Based subtracts total liabilities from total assets.
  • Capitalization divides the normalized cash flow you enter by the capitalization rate you enter.

Before you type anything, the fields already hold starting values, such as a 15% discount rate and 5% growth in the DCF method, a multiple of 10 and an 8% capitalization rate. They are set before the calculator has any figure from your business, so they are not figures for your business. No check of your figures, no adjustment and no outside data go into a result.

What the calculator can show you is what your own figures add up to under the method you picked. The result is recalculated from whatever is in the fields, so you can change one figure, such as the discount rate, and see how far the estimate moves. In the DCF method, the line under the result repeats the years, growth rate and discount rate used, for example “Projected cash flows over 5 years, 5% growth, 15% discount.”

How we describe the calculator

On Services & Pricing, we describe the calculator as “designed for educational purposes and early-stage planning” and say “Results are not certified appraisals.” The calculator page’s own disclaimer says it is “intended for general informational purposes only” and is not professional financial, legal or valuation advice. It also says its estimates “are based solely on the data you input and should not be relied upon for business decisions.”

What IRS guidance says about formulas and judgment

Revenue Ruling 59-60 is the IRS’s ruling on valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax. It defines these as corporations whose shares are owned by a relatively limited number of stockholders. It takes its definition of fair market value from the estate and gift tax regulations: the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under any compulsion and both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts. (The link opens an IRS job aid that reproduces the ruling in its Appendix A.)

The ruling says fair market value is a question of fact that depends on the circumstances of each case. It adds that no formula can be devised that is generally applicable to the many different valuation issues in estate and gift tax cases, and that valuation is not an exact science. A sound valuation, it says, is based on all the relevant facts, with common sense, informed judgment and reasonableness entering into how those facts are weighed.

IRS Publication 561, on valuing donated property, says that because of the many factors to be considered in valuing an interest in a closely held business, the help of experts is usually required. The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.4), written for its own staff who value businesses or review valuations, set out how those staff develop a business valuation. Neither the guidelines nor the ruling mentions calculators. Set against the calculator’s fields, though, they point to four things it leaves to you.

Four things the calculator leaves to you

Which method fits

The calculator page does not say which of its four methods fits your business. IRM 4.48.4 names three generally accepted approaches (asset-based, market and income), says all three should be considered, and says professional judgment should be used to select the approach and method that best indicate the value. Revenue Ruling 59-60 says earnings may be the most important criterion of value in some cases and asset value in others. In general, it says, the appraiser will give primary consideration to earnings for companies that sell products or services to the public, while for an investment or holding company the appraiser may give the greatest weight to the underlying assets.

If you try more than one method, note that the ruling sees no useful purpose in taking an average of several factors, such as book value, capitalized earnings and capitalized dividends, and basing the valuation on the result.

Which rates to use

The growth rate, discount rate, multiple and capitalization rate are figures you enter or accept from the starting values. Under IRM 4.48.4, the IRS appraiser determines the discount or capitalization rate after considering all relevant factors, such as the nature of the business, the risk involved, the company’s industry and the stability or irregularity of its earnings.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 says that determining the proper capitalization rate “presents one of the most difficult problems in valuation”. It notes that rates of return and dividend yields on listed shares vary widely, even for companies in the same industry, and change from year to year. So, it concludes, no standard tables of capitalization rates for closely held corporations can be formulated.

Whether your figures need adjusting

The calculator uses the cash flow, earnings, assets and liabilities you enter as they are. IRM 4.48.4 says historical financial statements should, if necessary, be analyzed and adjusted to reflect the appropriate asset value, income or cash flows, consistent with the methods the appraiser selected. Revenue Ruling 59-60 says that, with detailed profit-and-loss statements, the appraiser should be able to separate recurrent from nonrecurring items of income and expense. It adds that arbitrary five- or ten-year averages, without regard to current trends or future prospects, will not produce a realistic valuation.

What is valued, for what, and as of when

The calculator has no field for the purpose of the valuation, its date, or whether you are valuing the whole business or a share of it. Under IRM 4.48.4, the IRS appraiser should define the assignment by identifying several items, including:

  • the property and the interest to be valued
  • the effective valuation date
  • the purpose and the use of the valuation
  • the standard and definition of value

As appropriate for the assignment, the IRS appraiser also considers the interest’s marketability and its ability to control the operation, sale or liquidation of the business. Revenue Ruling 59-60 counts the size of the block of stock as a relevant factor. It notes that a minority interest in an unlisted corporation’s stock is more difficult to sell than a similar block of listed stock, while control of a corporation may justify a higher value for a specific block of stock.

A case study on this site describes an industrial equipment distributor valued first for gift and estate planning, and later to assess potential negotiations with prospective buyers. It reports that the different purposes and valuation dates led to substantially different results. That is one company, not a rule for others.

When an estimate is not enough

For investment, legal, tax or compliance purposes, the calculator page tells you to consult a licensed professional. Some uses also have official requirements of their own.

For example, if you claim a charitable deduction of more than $5,000 for an item or group of similar items of donated property, IRS Publication 561 says you generally must:

  • get a qualified appraisal, signed and dated by a qualified appraiser
  • attach Form 8283 to your tax return

Our article on business valuation costs and when you need more sets out that rule and the requirements for a gift tax return, for stock options and for an SBA loan to buy a business.

Our own Indicative Valuation report has limits too. The FAQ describes it as a choice when both of these apply:

  • the valuation does not need to be reviewed by an external party, which the FAQ gives as the IRS or litigation
  • it is used only for internal or strategic planning

Frequently asked questions

What methods does the free valuation calculator offer?

It offers four methods that you choose with buttons: DCF Method, Multiple Based, Asset Based and Capitalization. Each method uses only the figures in its own fields, and the result is recalculated from whatever is entered in them.

Do the calculator’s starting values describe my business?

No. The fields already hold starting values, such as a 15% discount rate and 5% growth in the DCF method, a multiple of 10 and an 8% capitalization rate. They are set before the calculator has any figure from your business, so they are not figures for your business.

Are the calculator’s results certified appraisals?

No. Services & Pricing describes the calculator as designed for educational purposes and early-stage planning and says its results are not certified appraisals. The calculator page adds that its estimates are based solely on the data you input and should not be relied upon for business decisions.

What does the calculator leave for the user to decide?

It leaves four things to the user: which method fits, which rates to use, whether the figures need adjusting, and what is valued, for what purpose and as of when. It has no field for the purpose of the valuation, its date, or whether the whole business or a share is valued.

What does IRS guidance say about using a formula to value a business?

Revenue Ruling 59-60 says no formula can be devised that is generally applicable to the many different valuation issues in estate and gift tax cases, and that valuation is not an exact science. A sound valuation rests on all relevant facts, with common sense, informed judgment and reasonableness.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.

Prefer to talk first? Book a free discovery call with Andrew Mackson or Ryan Maguire, partners at Los Angeles Business Valuations.