Case Study: Valuing an Equipment Distributor for Gift Planning, Then for Potential Talks With Buyers
An industrial equipment distributor was valued twice: first for gift and estate planning, and later to assess potential negotiations with prospective buyers. The different purposes and the different valuation dates led to substantially different results. This case study, first published in May 2024, sets out what each valuation covered and what it gave the client.
The first valuation: an equity interest to be gifted
The client was an industrial equipment distributor: a capable operator with strong margins and a good track record of revenue growth. Several months before this case study was first published, it asked for help with its gift and estate planning strategy. Its owner was approaching retirement, so an equity interest in the business was to be gifted. The company aimed to optimize its tax liability through a valuation of that interest.
The valuation determined the value of the equity stake being considered for the gift and applied discounts based on valuation theory and empirical evidence. The work meant navigating complex tax regulations and maximizing the discounts available, to address the client’s tax liability properly. The approach resulted in tax-efficient measures being put in place, reducing the client’s risks while preserving wealth for future generations.
Revenue Ruling 59-60, published by the IRS, outlines the approach, methods and factors to consider when valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax. It describes these as corporations whose shares are owned by a relatively limited number of stockholders. It says that property made the subject of a gift is taxed on the basis of its value at the date of the gift. Its text is reproduced in Appendix A of an IRS job aid for valuation analysts.
Among the factors the ruling says require careful analysis is the size of the block of stock to be valued. It notes that a minority interest in an unlisted corporation’s stock is more difficult to sell than a similar block of listed stock. Equally, control of a corporation may justify a higher value for a specific block of stock. The case does not name the regulations involved or the discounts applied, and does not say how large the gifted stake was.
The second valuation: assessing potential negotiations with buyers
A few weeks before this case study was first published, the client returned with a new objective: to assess potential negotiations with prospective buyers. The change of purpose reflected how the company’s circumstances and strategic priorities had evolved. Although the company being valued was the same, the new purpose called for a different method.
The second valuation used a methodology tailored to this purpose. It focused on market dynamics, private equity (PE) practices and the value drivers specific to the machinery distribution industry. It required a thorough understanding of those market dynamics and an assessment of how industry-specific factors affect valuation multiples.
The analysis gave the client insights for informed decision-making and for its strategic positioning in negotiations. The case does not say whether negotiations took place or whether the business was sold.
What an owner can take from this case
If your business has been valued before, this case is a reason to check whether that value fits a new purpose and a later date before you rely on it. What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.
Los Angeles Business Valuations’ FAQ describes its indicative valuation as a choice when both of these apply:
- the valuation does not need to be reviewed by an external party, which the FAQ gives as the IRS or litigation
- it is used only for internal or strategic planning
Related reading
- What Business Owners Use a Valuation For, and Where Our Report From $799 Fits
- Case Study: Valuation of a Pre-Revenue E-commerce Venture
- Automated Business Valuation: What Our Free Calculator Can and Cannot Tell You
Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.