Case Study: Valuation of a Pre-Revenue E-commerce Venture

Los Angeles Business Valuations was engaged by the owner of a pre-revenue e-commerce venture to value a 20% membership interest held by the venture’s incubator firm. The value was needed for tax purposes, and because the venture had no revenue yet, the valuation had to look forward, at its plans and prospects. This case study, first published here in May 2024, sets out the situation, what the valuation examined and what the client received.

The situation

The incubator was converting to a limited liability company (LLC) and required the assets to be valued for tax purposes. On the valuation date, the venture was still at the conceptual stage, without a live website or any material transactions. The challenge was to assess the financial prospects and potential value of a project that had barely begun.

What the valuation examined

Because the venture was at such an early stage, the valuation went beyond the usual financial measures. Its objective also included an evaluation of expected growth, the viability of the business plan, the product development strategy, how the portfolio was defined, capital requirements and the competitive landscape. The method was tailored to the venture’s circumstances. The work included:

  • The plan and the market. The venture’s business plan, product development strategy, market positioning and competitive landscape were analyzed.
  • The projections. The financial projections supplied for the valuation were assessed for reasonableness against the typical growth trajectories of similar businesses. That assessment took into account market trends, consumer behavior and industry dynamics.
  • The capital needed. Capital requirements were assessed against the venture’s expansion plans and the resources it would need.

What the forward-looking approach focused on

With no operating history to analyze, the valuation focused on three questions:

  • Was the business plan viable?
  • What demand might there be for the products the venture envisioned?
  • Could the venture carry out its growth strategy effectively?

What the client received

Los Angeles Business Valuations delivered a summary valuation report. By the firm’s account, the report served its main purpose: compliance with tax requirements. The firm also says the report gave the client insight into the potential value of the business and a clearer understanding of the venture’s financial prospects.

The case study does not give the valuation date, the value reached or the name of the valuation method.

What IRS guidance says about valuing an interest in a business

IRS Publication 561 is the IRS’s guide to determining the value of donated property. It also sets out general valuation principles for the income, gift and estate taxes. It says the fair market value of any interest in a closely held business is the amount a willing buyer would pay a willing seller for the interest, after considering all relevant factors. It lists factors that may help, and says the list is not all-inclusive:

  • the business’s net worth and prospective earning power;
  • the nature and history of the business;
  • the economic outlook of the industry it operates in;
  • its position in the industry, its competitors and its management;
  • the fair market value of its assets, including goodwill if applicable;
  • the value of interests in businesses in the same or similar industries.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 sets out the approach, methods and factors to be considered in valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax. It says the value of shares in a company with very uncertain future prospects is highly speculative. The appraiser must judge the degree of risk attaching to the business, and relate that judgment to all the other factors affecting value. It describes the valuation of securities as, in essence, a prediction about the future that must be based on the facts available at the required date of appraisal.

The IRS publishes the ruling’s text as an appendix to a job aid for its valuation analysts. The job aid itself is marked as not an official IRS position.

The case study does not say which tax rule its valuation was prepared under, or which standard of value it used. These passages describe IRS guidance in general, not what this engagement had to meet. What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.

If your valuation is for tax purposes

In the FAQ, the answer to “Is an indicative valuation right for me?” presents the $799 indicative valuation as a choice when the valuation:

  • is used for internal or strategic planning;
  • does not need to be reviewed by an external party (in the answer’s words, “the IRS or in litigation”).

It also says the indicative valuation is not as detailed as a full valuation and does not come with a detailed valuation report. If the IRS may review your valuation, read that answer before you choose a report.

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799, and you can order online. See Services & Pricing. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.