Case Study: Valuing Three Cash-Only Companies for IRS Forms Tied to a Tax Advantage

This case study, first published here in June 2024, describes the valuation of three special purpose vehicles (SPVs) whose balance sheets held only cash. The valuations were needed to fill in IRS forms that would let the owners gain a tax advantage. The page sets out the situation, what valuing such a company involves, what was delivered, and what IRS rules ask of a valuation of donated property.

The situation: three companies holding only cash

The tax advantage was tied to a donation: the SPVs donated an ownership interest that would allow their owners to gain it. The case study calls what the owners needed for the IRS forms a “certified valuation”. It does not say who received the interest, which tax advantage or forms were involved, or what the companies were worth.

Valuing a company that holds only cash

IRS Publication 561 defines fair market value as the price that would be agreed on between a willing buyer and a willing seller, with neither being required to act and both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts. For an interest in a closely held business, it says finding that value requires considering all available financial data and all relevant factors affecting it. It lists factors that may help, noting that the list is not all-inclusive:

  • the business’s net worth and prospective earning power
  • the nature and history of the business
  • the economic outlook of its industry
  • its position in the industry, its competitors and its management
  • the fair market value of its assets, including goodwill, if applicable
  • the value of interests in businesses in the same or similar industries

Because there are so many factors, the publication says, the help of experts is usually required. The case study’s point is that an SPV holding only cash on its balance sheet makes the valuation a much simpler matter: finding the fair market value of the company’s net assets.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 outlines the approach, methods and factors for valuing the stock of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax. It describes closely held corporations as those whose shares are owned by a relatively limited number of stockholders. It says that, in general, earnings get primary consideration for companies that sell products or services to the public. For an investment or holding type of company, the appraiser may give the greatest weight to the assets underlying the security being valued.

The ruling adds that, for a closely held investment or real estate holding company, the value of the stock is closely related to the value of the underlying assets. It says the appraiser should determine the fair market values of the company’s assets, and that the company’s operating expenses and the cost of liquidating it, if any, also merit consideration. The case study does not say how the three SPVs were organized.

What the engagement delivered

The case study says the valuations of the three SPVs were completed within five business days of receiving all the information needed. It says each was priced according to the complexity of its valuation, and that the work followed processes based on IRS guidelines and valuation standards, which it does not name. The engagement also included help filling in the necessary fields of the IRS forms. With the valuations and that help, the clients were able to apply for their tax advantages.

What IRS rules ask of a valuation of donated property

For a charitable contribution deduction, IRS Publication 561 speaks of a “qualified appraisal” completed by a “qualified appraiser”, and says many, but not all, charitable contributions require one. Generally, if you claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for an item or group of similar items of donated property, you must:

  • get a qualified appraisal signed and dated by a qualified appraiser
  • complete Form 8283 (Noncash Charitable Contributions) and attach it to your tax return

Among other requirements, a qualified appraisal must:

  • be made, signed and dated by a qualified appraiser in accordance with the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
  • be signed and dated no earlier than 60 days before the date of the contribution and no later than the due date, including extensions, of the return on which the deduction is first claimed
  • not involve a prohibited appraisal fee: generally, no part of the fee can be based on a percentage of the appraised value

A qualified appraiser is an individual with verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property being appraised. Among other conditions, they hold an appraisal designation for that type of property from a generally recognized professional appraiser organization, or meet minimum education requirements and have 2 or more years of experience valuing it. They must also regularly prepare appraisals for which they are paid. The case study does not say whether the three valuations were qualified appraisals in this sense.

The IRS does not recognize any particular appraiser or organization of appraisers, and it does not accept appraisals without question. Fees you pay for appraisals of donated property cannot be deducted as a charitable contribution.

Under Treasury Regulation §301.6501(c)-1(f), if a gift is not adequately disclosed on the federal gift tax return (Form 709), the gift tax on it may be assessed at any time. Adequate disclosure includes a detailed description of the method used to determine fair market value, including the financial data used, such as balance sheets. An appraisal that meets the regulation’s requirements can take the place of that description. Another article on this site, on what business valuations cost and when you need more, also covers these charitable deduction and gift tax rules.

The $799 report sold on this site is the indicative valuation. The site’s FAQ says it is not as detailed as a full valuation and does not come with a detailed valuation report. It recommends it for valuations used for internal or strategic planning that do not need to be reviewed by an external party such as the IRS.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.