SaaS Business Valuation: What IRS Valuation Rules Ask an Appraiser to Weigh

This page sets out what official US tax guidance asks an appraiser to consider when valuing shares in a company that is not publicly traded, and where those points bear on a software or SaaS (software as a service) company. It gives no benchmark multiples for software companies, because none of the official sources it relies on publishes any.

What is being valued, for what purpose, and to what standard

The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.4) are written for IRS staff who value businesses or review valuations prepared by others. They have the appraiser define the assignment by identifying, among other things, the property and the interest to be valued, the effective valuation date, the purpose and use of the valuation, and the standard and definition of value. For a software company, that settles whether the whole company or a block of its shares is being valued, at what date, and for what purpose, for example a gift of shares or setting the exercise price of stock options.

For estate and gift tax, and for stock options under section 409A, the standard is fair market value. Revenue Ruling 59-60, the IRS’s ruling on valuing shares of closely held companies for estate and gift tax, gives the definition from the estate and gift tax regulations: the price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or to sell, and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts. The IRS publishes the ruling’s full text as Appendix A of a job aid for its valuation analysts; the job aid itself is marked as not an official IRS position. A closely held company is one whose shares are owned by a relatively limited number of stockholders, so little, if any, trading in its shares takes place and there is no established market for its stock. When stock is closely held, some other measure of value must be used.

The ruling offers no formula. A determination of fair market value is a question of fact that depends on the circumstances of each case, and valuation is not an exact science. Valuing shares is, in the ruling’s words, “a prophesy as to the future”, and it must be based on facts available at the valuation date.

The factors an appraiser must consider, applied to a software company

Revenue Ruling 59-60 lists eight factors that, although not all-inclusive, “are fundamental and require careful analysis in each case”. The IRS’s 2020 Business Valuation Guidelines give its appraisers the same eight, with two additions: a later sale of the shares that was reasonably foreseeable at the valuation date, and other relevant information. The factors follow, each with what it points to in a software company where the ruling’s wording allows.

The nature and history of the business

A company’s history shows its past stability or instability, its growth or lack of growth and the diversity or lack of diversity of its operations, which helps the appraiser judge the degree of risk in the business. The history studied includes the nature of the business, its products or services, its operating and investment assets, its capital structure, its sales records and its management. The detail considered should increase closer to the valuation date, since recent events are of greatest help in predicting the future, and past events unlikely to recur should be discounted. For a software company, expect the appraiser to ask how its product and its sales record have developed, in most detail for the latest period.

The economy, the industry and competition

A sound appraisal must consider current and prospective economic conditions at the valuation date, in the national economy and in the company’s industry, and it is important to know whether the company is more or less successful than its competitors. Competition that has not been a factor before should be given careful attention: the ruling’s example is that high profits due to the novelty of a product and a lack of competition often lead to increasing competition.

The same factor covers dependence on one person. The loss of the manager of a so-called “one-man” business may have a depressing effect on the value of its stock, particularly if there is a lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to its management. Offsetting factors, such as life insurance covering the loss, or competent management that could be employed with what was paid for the former manager’s services, are weighed against it. If your software company depends on you as its manager, the effect of losing you on its future and the absence of anyone able to succeed you in its management are factors to be taken into consideration.

Book value and financial condition

The ruling asks for balance sheets, preferably comparative annual statements for two or more years before the valuation date, which usually show liquidity, fixed assets, working capital, long-term debt, capital structure and net worth. Assets not essential to running the business, such as investments in securities or real estate, are also considered. Where a company has more than one class of stock, its charter should be examined for each class’s voting powers, preference as to dividends and preference as to assets in a liquidation. If your company has issued preferred stock to investors, expect the appraiser to read those terms.

Earning capacity

Detailed profit-and-loss statements should be obtained for a representative period before the valuation date, preferably five or more years. With them the appraiser should be able to separate recurrent from nonrecurring items of income and expense, and to see whether any line of business is operated consistently at a loss. Potential future income is a major factor in many valuations of closely held stock, and arbitrary five- or ten-year averages that ignore current trends or future prospects will not produce a realistic valuation. Where net income has been progressively increasing or decreasing, the most recent years’ profits may be given greater weight in estimating earning power.

Dividend-paying capacity

Primary consideration goes to the company’s capacity to pay dividends rather than to the dividends it actually paid, and that holds for a software company that has never paid one. Recognition must also be given to the need to retain a reasonable portion of profits to meet competition. When a controlling interest is valued, dividends are not a material element, because paying them is at the controlling stockholders’ discretion.

Goodwill and other intangible value

In the ruling, goodwill is based on earning capacity: its presence and value rest on the excess of net earnings over a fair return on the net tangible assets. The prestige and renown of the business, the ownership of a trade or brand name, and a record of successful operation over a prolonged period in a particular locality may also support intangible value. The IRS’s guidelines for valuing intangible property (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.5) list computer software as the first of their seven categories of intangible property, and include customer lists in another.

Earlier sales of the shares, and the size of the block

Past sales of a closely held company’s shares should be investigated to see whether they were at arm’s length; forced or distress sales do not ordinarily reflect fair market value, and isolated sales in small amounts do not necessarily control as the measure of value. The size of the block being valued is itself relevant: a minority interest in an unlisted company is more difficult to sell than a similar block of listed stock, while control may justify a higher value for a specific block. Where appropriate, and where not already considered in weighing the other indications of value, the IRS guidelines have the appraiser consider separately the interest’s marketability, its ability to control the operation, sale or liquidation of the business, and other levels of value such as strategic or synergistic contributions.

Prices of comparable companies with traded shares

The appraiser takes into account the market price of shares in companies in the same or a similar line of business whose shares are actively traded in a free and open market, on an exchange or over the counter. Care should be taken to use only comparable companies, and being in the same or a similar line of business is not enough on its own: other relevant factors must be considered to obtain the most valid comparison possible. The ruling gives two examples: a company with preferred stock, bonds or debentures as well as common stock is not directly comparable to one with only common stock, and a company with a declining business and decreasing markets is not comparable to one with a record of current progress and market expansion.

How much weight each factor gets

Depending on the circumstances, some factors carry more weight than others because of the nature of the company’s business. In general, primary consideration goes to earnings for companies that sell products or services to the public, while for an investment or holding company the greatest weight may go to the assets underlying the stock. A software company that sells its product or service to the public, rather than holding investments, falls on the earnings side of that general rule. The ruling also rules out a shortcut: because the factors cannot be assigned mathematical weights, no useful purpose is served by averaging several of them, such as book value, capitalized earnings and capitalized dividends, and basing the valuation on the result.

The three approaches

The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines name three generally accepted approaches: the asset-based approach, the market approach and the income approach. Consideration should be given to all three, and professional judgment selects the approaches, and the methods within them, that best indicate the value of the interest. Historical financial statements may need to be adjusted to be consistent with the methods chosen. The appraiser selects a benefit stream, such as pre-tax or after-tax income or cash flows, and discount rates, capitalization rates or multiples consistent with it. In setting a discount or capitalization rate, the appraiser considers all relevant factors, such as the nature of the business, the risk involved, the company’s industry and the stability or irregularity of its earnings.

The IRS’s separate guidelines for intangible property, such as software valued on its own, describe the methods in more detail. Market-based methods rely on similar intangible property sold under similar conditions and require an active market involving comparable property. Cost-based methods estimate the cost to reproduce, replace or buy the property, though the cost approach may be difficult to apply because of problems quantifying economic obsolescence or future income potential. Income-based methods focus on the property’s capacity to produce income: the present value of the net economic benefit to be received over the asset’s life can estimate its value, and the income approach usually computes this with the discounted cash flow (DCF) method. The final opinion of value should reconcile the results of the methods applied. This site has an article on the discounted cash flow (DCF) method.

Why this page gives no ARR multiple

Neither Revenue Ruling 59-60 nor the IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines mentions annual recurring revenue (ARR) or subscriptions, and neither gives a multiple or a rate for any industry. On rates the ruling is explicit: no standard tables of capitalization rates applicable to closely held companies can be formulated, because the rates of return and dividend yields of listed shares vary widely even for companies in the same industry, and fluctuate from year to year with economic conditions. If an appraiser uses multiples drawn from other companies’ share prices, the ruling’s tests for comparable companies apply to those companies. What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.

Valuing startup stock for option grants (section 409A)

If your company grants stock options, the Treasury regulations under section 409A of the tax code set their own valuation rule. For a nonstatutory option on the company’s stock, one of the conditions for it not to provide for a deferral of compensation is that its exercise price can never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock on the date the option is granted.

For stock that is not readily tradable on an established securities market, fair market value means a value determined by the reasonable application of a reasonable valuation method, judged on the facts and circumstances at the valuation date. The factors to consider include, as applicable, the value of the company’s tangible and intangible assets, the present value of its anticipated future cash flows, the market value of stock in substantially similar businesses whose value can be readily determined by objective means, recent arm’s length transactions in the stock, and control premiums or discounts for lack of marketability. A method is not reasonable if it does not take into consideration all available information material to the company’s value. A value calculated earlier stops being reasonable if it fails to reflect later information that may materially affect the company’s value, or if it was calculated for a date more than 12 months before the date it is used for.

Some methods are presumed to give a reasonable valuation, although the presumption can be rebutted by showing that the method or its application was grossly unreasonable. One is an independent appraisal meeting the requirements of section 401(a)(28)(C) of the tax code and its regulations, as of a date no more than 12 months before the transaction it is applied to, such as the grant of a stock option.

Another presumption applies only to illiquid stock of a start-up: a valuation made reasonably and in good faith and evidenced by a written report that takes the factors above into account. A start-up here is a company with no material trade or business that it or a predecessor has conducted for 10 years or more and no class of equity securities traded on an established securities market, whose stock is not subject to put, call or other purchase rights apart from two exceptions set out in the regulation. That route does not apply if, when the valuation is applied, it can reasonably be anticipated that the company will undergo a change in control within the 90 days, or make a public offering within the 180 days, following the action the valuation is applied to. For that route, the valuation must be performed by someone the company reasonably determines is qualified based on significant knowledge, experience, education or training; significant experience generally means at least five years of relevant experience in business valuation or appraisal, financial accounting, investment banking, private equity, secured lending, or other comparable experience in the company’s line of business or industry.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.