Insurance Agency Business Valuation in California
The IRS’s Revenue Ruling 59-60, written for valuing stock for estate and gift tax, says an appraiser will in general give primary consideration to earnings when valuing the stock of a company that sells products or services to the public, as an insurance agency does. In California, an agency’s earnings depend on licensed people and on insurers: every licensee who acts under an agency’s license must be endorsed on it, and the agency may not sell insurance until an insurer has completed a notice appointing it. This page sets out what a buyer of a California agency can take over, how the price of an asset sale is split for tax, what an SBA 7(a) loan may finance in an agency purchase, and what to prepare.
What an agency’s license depends on
California’s Insurance Code defines, among other roles, these two. An insurance agent transacts insurance, other than life, disability or health insurance, on behalf of an admitted insurance company. An insurance broker transacts that insurance for compensation and on behalf of another person, with but not on behalf of an admitted insurer. A licensee is presumed to act as a broker when, among other conditions, a written agreement signed by the consumer discloses the broker fees charged and, if applicable, that the licensee may be entitled to compensation from the insurer.
A corporation, LLC or partnership that runs an agency can hold a business entity license from the California Department of Insurance (CDI). The CDI’s guidance for business entities sets these conditions:
- Every licensed person who will act under the entity’s license must be endorsed on it, and when it applies for its license, the entity must name at least one natural person who holds, or is applying for, an individual license.
- The entity may not transact, solicit or negotiate the sale of insurance until an insurer admitted in California has completed an Action Notice of Appointment for it.
- The entity’s officers do not have to be licensed.
Two of these depend on people other than the seller. Endorsed licensees are individuals, and the entity may terminate an agent who is no longer authorized to transact under its license; appointments are completed by insurers.
How the agency’s earnings are judged
Revenue Ruling 59-60, the IRS’s guidance for valuing stock of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax, lists factors that require careful analysis in each case; the IRS publishes its text as an appendix to a job aid for its valuation analysts. Among them are the nature and history of the business, the outlook of its industry, its earning capacity and whether it has goodwill. Goodwill, the ruling says, is in the final analysis based on earning capacity.
Uncertainty about the stability or continuity of future income decreases value by increasing the risk of losing earnings and value in the future. For an agency, that is the question of how much of its income, from insurers and from client fees, will continue under a new owner, with the licensees and appointments described above. How the quality of commission revenue affects an agency’s value is the subject of a separate article.
The ruling also addresses dependence on one person. The loss of the manager of a so-called “one-man” business may depress the value of its stock, particularly if there is a lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to the management. Offsetting factors, such as competent management that could be employed in the manager’s place, are weighed against that loss.
When the buyer takes over the licensed entity
If ownership of the licensed entity changes, the CDI requires the Business Entity Disclosure Form (LIC BED-1), with a cover letter giving details of the change, under Insurance Code section 1656.1. The same form reports new officers, directors, managers, members or stockholders.
If the agency is merged into another licensed entity, the surviving entity writes to the CDI asking for the non-survivor’s license to be canceled, and reports changes in its own officers, managers, members, partners and stockholders on the LIC BED-1 form. If the surviving entity’s federal employer identification number (FEIN) changes because of the merger, it must apply for a new business entity license.
The CDI’s guidance stops there. It does not describe the sale of a book of business on its own, and it does not say what happens to an appointment or to commissions when an agency changes hands. Because appointments are completed by insurers, a valuation should not assume that each one continues after a sale.
Buying the agency’s name
Each licensed agent or business entity may have one approved fictitious (DBA) name. Another can be added only “by right of purchase”, meaning the right to use a name approved for the seller was bought (Insurance Code section 1724.5(e)). A buyer of a DBA name notifies the CDI with a Name Approval Request (LIC 447-42A) and a statement signed by the seller asking to cancel the seller’s DBA and releasing the name to the buyer.
Showing client information to a buyer
If a buyer or a valuer asks for information about the agency’s clients, California’s Insurance Information and Privacy Protection Act limits what the agency may disclose about individuals. It bars an agent from disclosing personal or privileged information about an individual collected in an insurance transaction, except in the cases it lists. “Agent” there includes anyone licensed under Chapter 5 of the Insurance Code, the chapter that defines insurance agents and brokers, and personal information includes a person’s name and address.
One listed case is disclosure to a party, or a party’s representative, in a proposed or completed sale, transfer, merger or consolidation of all or part of the business. Before the deal closes, only information reasonably necessary for the recipient’s business decisions about the purchase may be disclosed. The recipient must also agree not to disclose it further unless the same section of the Act would allow the agency to make that disclosure. So before closing, decide what the buyer needs to see for its decision, and have the buyer’s agreement in place first.
How the price is split for tax in an asset sale
When a group of assets that makes up a trade or business is sold, the buyer and the seller generally both file IRS Form 8594 with their income tax returns, if goodwill or going concern value attaches or could attach to the assets and the buyer’s basis is set only by the amount paid. The form sorts the price into classes. Class VI holds section 197 intangibles other than goodwill and going concern value: among them any customer-based intangible, workforce in place, business books and records, any license or permit granted by a government unit, a covenant not to compete made in connection with the acquisition, and a trade name. Class VII is goodwill and going concern value.
Under the Treasury regulations, customer-based intangibles include the part of a purchase price attributable to a customer base or to another relationship with customers involving the future provision of goods or services. An agency’s book of clients fits that description. Subject to the exceptions in the statute, the buyer amortizes an acquired section 197 intangible held in its business ratably over 15 years, beginning with the month of acquisition.
The price is allocated class by class, and except for Class VII, no asset may be allocated more than its fair market value on the purchase date; what remains goes to goodwill and going concern value. So reporting an asset sale of an agency calls for the fair market value of each asset other than goodwill and going concern value, not only the total price. If the amount allocated to an asset is increased or decreased after the year of the sale, whoever is affected completes Parts I and III of Form 8594 and attaches it to the return for the year the change is taken into account.
If the buyer uses an SBA 7(a) loan
Under the SBA’s SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a 7(a) loan may finance a change of ownership that includes intangible assets, among them goodwill, client or customer lists and agreements not to compete, as long as the SOP’s financial due diligence requirements are met. Seller earnouts are prohibited, although buyer rebates based on business performance are allowed.
The general SBA and IRS rules are covered in Business Valuation Requirements for SBA 7(a) Loans to Buy a Business and Certified or Qualified Business Appraisers: What IRS and SBA Rules Require.
What to prepare
- The agency’s license record and the licensees endorsed on it; the CDI’s Check a License service searches license status by license number or name.
- A list of the insurers that have appointed the agency.
- Records of the entity’s owners and officers.
- The agency’s approved name and any DBA.
- For an LLC, its annual Certification of Coverage (LIC CC1), which shows it still meets the financial security requirements of Insurance Code section 1647.5.
- If you act as a broker, the signed client agreements described above.
- Client information, limited before closing to what the buyer needs for its decision.
Frequently asked questions
Do an agency’s officers need an insurance license?
No. The CDI says the officers of a business entity do not have to be licensed. When it applies for its license, the entity must name at least one natural person who holds or is applying for an individual license, and every licensee acting under its license must be endorsed on it.
Do insurer appointments pass to the buyer?
The CDI’s guidance does not say. Appointments are completed by insurers, and a licensed agency may not sell insurance until one is, so a valuation should not assume that they pass.
Can I show my client list to a prospective buyer?
California’s Insurance Information and Privacy Protection Act allows disclosure to a party to a proposed sale of all or part of the business, on two conditions. Only information reasonably necessary for the buyer’s business decisions may be disclosed before closing, and the buyer must agree not to disclose it further unless the same section of the Act would allow the agency to make that disclosure.
Related reading
- MGA (Managing General Agent) Valuation in California
- Certified or Qualified Business Appraisers: What IRS and SBA Rules Require
- SaaS Business Valuation: What IRS Valuation Rules Ask an Appraiser to Weigh
Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.
Prefer to talk first? Book a free discovery call with Andrew Mackson or Ryan Maguire, partners at Los Angeles Business Valuations.