Case Study: Valuation of an Early-Stage Global Digital Advertising Agency

Los Angeles Business Valuations was engaged by the owner of a rapidly growing digital advertising agency, founded in 2019, to value it for internal planning and a possible transaction with outside investors. The firm judged the market approach unreliable, given the skewed financial metrics available, so the valuation centered on the income approach, using a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis. This page sets out the agency and the engagement’s purpose, the two problems the valuation faced, the method, what the report contained and what the account leaves out.

The agency and what the engagement was for

At the time, the agency had been in business for less than five years. In that time it had grown fast, expanding into markets including the USA, Canada, China and Europe. It had also spread its services across sectors such as e-commerce, insurance, finance and legal services.

The engagement had two objectives:

  • insight into the agency’s current value, to support strategic decisions;
  • a defensible valuation to present to potential investors, to help the transaction go smoothly.

Two problems the valuation had to deal with

  • How the accounts were kept. The agency’s financial records showed high revenue paired with equally high direct costs, which left low gross profit. The firm found this way of accounting out of line with industry practice, which made the agency hard to compare with other companies.
  • No formal growth plan. Without a formal growth strategy, it was difficult to project the agency’s future earnings and to understand its long-term potential.

Why the market approach was judged unreliable

The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.4), written for its own valuation staff, name three generally accepted approaches: the asset-based approach, the market approach and the income approach. They say all three should be considered, and that professional judgment selects the approach, and the method within it, that best indicates the value.

For this agency, the market approach was judged unreliable. The reason given: the financial metrics available were skewed, and comparable companies typically report more consistent profit margins. That made accurate comparisons difficult to draw.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 is the IRS’s ruling on valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax. On choosing companies to compare with, it says care should be taken to use only comparable companies. Being in the same or a similar line of business is not enough on its own: other relevant factors must be considered to obtain the most valid comparison possible. The IRS publishes the ruling’s text as an appendix to a job aid for its valuation analysts.

How the agency was valued

The valuation centered on the income approach and had three parts.

  1. Adjusting the financial statements. The agency’s financial statements were analyzed, and anomalies in its revenue and cost structures were identified and adjusted, to give a more accurate picture of its financial performance. The IRS guidelines also say that historical financial statements should, if necessary, be analyzed and adjusted to be consistent with the valuation methods the appraiser selects.
  2. A discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis. It was chosen because the agency was at an early stage and on a high growth trajectory. In the firm’s account, the method allowed the valuation to take in both the agency’s future earnings potential and the risks that came with the business. Under the IRS guidelines, the appraiser sets a discount or capitalization rate after considering all relevant factors. They include the nature of the business, the risk involved, the company’s industry and the stability or irregularity of its earnings.
  3. Market data as a check. Direct market comparisons were limited, but market data was used to validate the growth assumptions and industry benchmarks behind the projections.

What the report gave the client

The client received a summary valuation report that provided:

  • An adjusted financial analysis. It showed the agency’s profitability on the adjusted figures, giving a clearer understanding of its financial position and its potential for future growth.
  • A valuation range. The DCF analysis produced a valuation range for the client to use as a basis for approaching potential investors.
  • Recommendations. The report recommended improving the agency’s financial reporting practices and developing a formal growth plan. Their stated aim was to improve future valuations and the agency’s appeal to investors. Each recommendation responds to one of the two problems described above.

What the published account does not say

This is the firm’s own account of the engagement, first published on this site in July 2024. It does not name the client, and it gives no figures: not the agency’s revenue or margins, not the rates used in the DCF analysis and not the valuation range itself. It does not say whether a transaction with investors followed.

What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.