409A Valuation for SaaS Start-ups: Rounds, Repricing, Exits

If your SaaS start-up grants nonstatutory stock options, one condition for an option not to count as deferred compensation under the section 409A regulation is that its exercise price can never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock on the grant date. How that value is set, which valuations the regulation presumes reasonable, who may prepare them and what the statute provides when a plan fails are explained in 409A Valuation Rules for Stock Option Grants. The regulation never mentions software or SaaS companies; this article covers what comes after a founder’s first valuation: vesting clauses, later news, a coming sale, changes to granted options, incentive stock options and advisers.

Vesting, buy-back and first-refusal clauses

Two of the regulation’s rules turn on how your stock agreements restrict the shares. The fair market value an exercise price is measured against disregards lapse restrictions. The presumption for a written report on illiquid stock of a start-up (the start-up presumption) does not cover stock subject to a put, call or other right or obligation to purchase it, with two exceptions:

  • a right of first refusal on an offer from a third party unrelated to the company and the option holder;
  • a right or obligation that is a lapse restriction.

The section 83 regulation, §1.83-3, defines the terms:

  • A nonlapse restriction is a permanent limit on transfer that requires the holder to sell, or offer to sell, at a formula price, and that is enforced against any later holder too. A permanent right of first refusal at a formula price is one; an obligation to sell to a specific person at fair market value at the time of sale is not.
  • A lapse restriction is any other restriction, including one that carries a substantial risk of forfeiture.
  • A substantial risk of forfeiture exists, apart from two special cases, only if rights in the property are conditioned on the future performance (or non-performance) of substantial services, or on a condition related to a purpose of the transfer where forfeiture is a substantial possibility; it depends on the facts and circumstances.

Before relying on the start-up presumption, check each vesting, buy-back, put, call and first-refusal clause against these definitions.

Funding rounds, patents and other news after the valuation date

An earlier value is no longer reasonable to use once it was calculated for a date more than 12 months before, or if it misses later information that may materially affect the company’s value, as the 409A rules page explains. The regulation’s two examples of such information are “the resolution of material litigation or the issuance of a patent”: if your company has patent applications pending, a patent issued on one of them is news to weigh before the next grant.

A financing round, a change in recurring revenue or the loss of a large customer is not among them, though the two are only examples; reasonableness is judged on the facts and circumstances as of the valuation date. A round also feeds the next valuation: the factors include “recent arm’s length transactions involving the sale or transfer of such stock or equity interests”. What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.

Acquisition talks, an IPO and the 90- and 180-day windows

The start-up presumption does not apply if, when the valuation is applied, the company or the option holder may reasonably anticipate a change in control event described in §1.409A-3(i)(5)(v) or (vii) within 90 days after the action the valuation is applied to, such as a grant, or a public offering within 180 days. The regulation’s rules on change in control events, §1.409A-3(i)(5), define the two:

  • A change in the ownership of the company: one person, or more than one acting as a group, acquires stock that, with the stock it already holds, is more than 50 percent of the total fair market value or total voting power of the company’s stock. A new issue of stock counts. Further purchases by someone already above 50 percent, or by someone already considered to control the company effectively under the same rules, do not.
  • A change in the ownership of a substantial portion of its assets: one person or group acquires from the company, within a 12-month period, assets with a total gross fair market value (before liabilities) of 40 percent or more of all its assets just before. Transfers to certain related persons, such as an entity the company owns 50 percent or more of, are excepted.

Investors are not treated as a group solely because they buy or own stock at the same time; owners of a corporation that enters into a merger, acquisition of stock or similar transaction with your company are. A round that takes one investor from no more than 50 percent of both the total fair market value and the total voting power to more than 50 percent of either is a change in ownership, unless that investor was already considered to control the company effectively under these rules. A third kind of event in the same rules, a change in effective control, is not named by the start-up presumption.

Changing options after they are granted

Lowering the exercise price

Apart from exceptions set out in the section 409A regulation’s rules on changing stock rights, §1.409A-1(b)(5)(v), any change to an option, or to the plan or agreement governing it, that may give the holder a direct or indirect reduction in the exercise price is a modification, whether or not the holder benefits. A modification is treated as the grant of a new option, tested at its new grant date: the exercise price is measured against the stock’s fair market value on that date.

Giving a departing employee longer to exercise

Giving the holder more time to exercise than originally set is an extension, and an extended option is treated as providing for a deferral of compensation from its original grant date. The exceptions include these:

  • moving the expiry to a date no later than the earlier of the latest date the option could have expired under its original terms in any circumstances and the 10th anniversary of the original grant;
  • extending it while the exercise price equals or exceeds the stock’s fair market value, which is instead treated as a modification and a new grant;
  • suspending expiry while exercising would violate an applicable law or jeopardize the company’s ability to continue as a going concern, for no more than 30 days after that ends.

Options substituted or assumed in a corporate transaction

If, in a corporate transaction as defined in §1.424-1(a)(3), a new option is substituted for yours or yours is assumed, that is not a new grant where §1.424-1’s requirements would be met if it were a statutory option (leaving aside the requirement that an eligible corporation be the holder’s employer). One of them, §1.424-1(a)(5)(iii), is treated as met if the ratio of exercise price to the shares’ fair market value is not greater right after than right before. The other requirements of §1.424-1 are not covered here.

Incentive stock options follow section 422’s price rule

Granting an incentive stock option is not a deferral of compensation under the 409A regulation, unless a later modification, extension or renewal is treated as the grant of a new option that is not a statutory option. Its own regulation, §1.422-2, sets the price rule:

  • The option price must not be less than the stock’s fair market value when the option is granted, and may be set in any reasonable manner.
  • An option that fails only because a good-faith attempt to meet that rule fell short is treated as meeting it. For stock that is not publicly traded, showing, for example, that the value was based on an average of the values in the opinions of completely independent and well-qualified experts generally establishes a good-faith attempt.
  • No good-faith attempt is shown unless the value takes nonlapse restrictions into account and disregards lapse restrictions.
  • If, immediately before the grant, the holder owns or is treated as owning stock with more than 10 percent of the total combined voting power of all classes of stock of the employer or a related corporation, the option qualifies only if its price is at least 110 percent of fair market value on the grant date and it cannot be exercised more than 5 years after the grant. The good-faith rule does not apply to that minimum price, and stock the holder may buy under outstanding options is not counted as owned.

Options for independent advisers and contractors

Section 409A does not apply to an amount deferred with a service provider who, in the taxable year it obtains the legally binding right to the amount, meets all three conditions of the regulation’s rule for independent contractors, §1.409A-1(f)(2):

  • it is actively engaged in a business of providing services, other than as an employee or board member;
  • it provides significant services to two or more service recipients not related to it or to one another;
  • it is not related to your company, under a definition that makes a corporation’s officer related to it.

The exception does not reach management services: actual or de facto direction or control of the business’s financial or operational aspects.

Cap table, round documents, forecasts and agreements to hand over

  • The charter, each round’s documents and a list of share sales or transfers since the last valuation: recent arm’s length transactions are a factor.
  • Revenue history and the forecast: the present value of anticipated future cash flows is a factor.
  • Software, patents, applications and other intangible assets, whose value is also a factor. How IRS guidance treats software as intangible property is covered in SaaS Business Valuation: What IRS Valuation Rules Ask an Appraiser to Weigh.
  • Stock and option agreements, with every vesting, buy-back, put, call and first-refusal clause.
  • The company’s history, including any predecessor’s: for the start-up presumption, the company may have no material trade or business that it or any predecessor has conducted for 10 years or more.
  • Any acquisition talks or offering plans, and, if incentive stock options are planned, the voting power each holder owns.

If your start-up has preferred stock, convertible debt instruments and multiple rounds of financing, Los Angeles Business Valuations’ FAQ calls that a complex capital structure. It says the firm’s valuations can be used for 409A valuations, and that with such a structure more detailed information is needed and the fee could increase a little. On Services & Pricing, 409A is one of the external purposes listed on the Summary Valuation / Appraisal card, which shows “Contact for Pricing”. Neither page says which presumption, if any, a report is prepared to meet, so ask before relying on one.

Frequently asked questions

I own more than 10 percent of my company’s voting power. Can I be granted incentive stock options?

An option granted to you can qualify only if its price is at least 110 percent of the stock’s fair market value on the grant date and it cannot be exercised more than 5 years after the grant; the other incentive stock option requirements apply as well. Stock you may buy under outstanding options is not treated as owned by you.

Does a right of first refusal on our shares rule out the start-up presumption?

Not if it is a right of first refusal on an offer from a third party unrelated to the company and the option holder. The presumption does not cover stock subject to a put, call or other right or obligation to purchase it, but it excepts that kind of right, and a right or obligation that is a lapse restriction.

Does a funding round with several investors count as a change in control?

Not because they buy at the same time: that alone does not make them a group. A round is a change in ownership if it takes one investor from no more than 50 percent of both the total fair market value and the total voting power to more than 50 percent of either, unless that investor was already considered to control the company effectively. A change in effective control is a separate kind of change in control event, which the start-up presumption does not name.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.