Development Company NAV: Land Appraisals and Book Cost

For a company that mainly holds real estate, the IRS’s ruling on valuing closely held shares for gift and estate tax puts the fair market value of its assets ahead of its earnings. California law defines an appraisal as developing an opinion of value for real property, and only a licensee of the Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers (BREA) may sign one in a federally related transaction. Under US accounting standards, the balance sheet capitalizes something else: the costs clearly associated with acquiring, developing and constructing each project.

When the assets, not the earnings, carry the value

That ruling, Revenue Ruling 59-60 (the IRS prints it in an appendix to its S corporation valuation job aid), in general puts earnings first for companies that sell products or services to the public; for a real estate holding company, it has the appraiser determine the fair market values of the assets and give adjusted net worth greater weight. The ruling does not say where a company that develops property for sale falls. The valuation has to decide that from what your company actually does.

The other sides of a developer’s valuation are covered in California Home and Lot Developers: Public Reports, Licenses and, for apartment projects, Multifamily Developer Valuation: Los Angeles Covenants.

In the site’s free business valuation calculator, the “Asset Based” method gives a net asset value (NAV) as “Net assets (total assets minus total liabilities).” It uses only the figures you type in, with no adjustment or outside data. Land entered at its book cost therefore stays at cost in the net asset figure.

How a property appraiser reaches a value

The IRS’s guidelines for its own real property appraisers (IRM 4.48.6) count among the interests they value fractional interests and real property held in partnerships, corporations and trusts. They have the appraiser consider approaches such as these, and leave the choice to professional judgment:

  • Sales comparison. Sales of property with a similar highest and best use, sold close to the valuation date, adjusted for financing, conditions of sale, date, physical characteristics, location and any other significant differences.
  • Cost. The reproduction or replacement cost of the improvements, less depreciation and obsolescence, plus the value of the land. The guidelines call it generally useful for specialty properties where other approaches lack supporting data and the land value and depreciation can reasonably be determined.
  • Income. A projected income stream, based on income and expense history, vacancy, rent rolls, leases and market conditions, converted to present value with a capitalization technique that reflects typical investors in that type of property. Discount and capitalization rates should be justified with reliable market data, industry surveys or market-supported methods.

The appraiser should explain any approach left out. Where appropriate, and if the approaches have not already taken them into account, they should also separately consider factors that include marketability and control (or the lack of them), the legal form of ownership, and the effect of contractual and legal restrictions.

Projects not yet built or not yet sold get specific treatment in the FDIC’s appraisal rule. For a federally related transaction with a bank the FDIC regulates, such as a loan secured by the property, the appraisal must analyze and report appropriate deductions and discounts for proposed construction and for tract developments with unsold units. A tract development is a project of five or more units built, or to be built, as a single development. The rule does not set the size of those deductions.

Who may appraise real property in California

California’s Real Estate Appraisers’ Licensing and Certification Law defines an appraisal as developing an opinion of value for real property. An opinion that a real estate licensee, engineer or land surveyor gives in the ordinary course of that licensed work is not an appraisal under this law and may not be called one. The law also says:

  • No one may engage in federally related real estate appraisal activity, or use the title of a licensed appraiser, without an active BREA license.
  • Only a licensee may sign an appraisal in a federally related transaction; a trainee may sign one if a licensee signs it too.
  • Only licensees at a certified level may use the term “state certified real estate appraiser” in their real property appraisal business.
  • A licensee may not engage in any appraisal activity if their pay depends on, or is affected by, the value the appraisal concludes.
  • The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) are the minimum standard for a licensee’s work wherever those standards address it.

Under that law, a federally related transaction is a real estate-related financial transaction that a federal financial institutions regulatory agency engages in, contracts for or regulates, and that requires a state licensed appraiser, or one that such an agency identifies as federally related. For banks the FDIC regulates, its appraisal rule counts as real estate-related financial transactions the sale, purchase, lease or exchange of real property, investment in it, its financing or refinancing, and its use as security for a loan. It requires an appraisal by a state certified or licensed appraiser for all of them except listed cases, which include:

  • a commercial real estate transaction of $500,000 or less;
  • a business loan of $1 million or less that does not depend on the sale of, or rental income from, real estate as its primary source of repayment.

In those two cases the bank must still obtain an appropriate evaluation of the property. A state certified appraiser is required for any federally related transaction of $1,000,000 or more, and for commercial real estate transactions over $500,000.

BREA issues four license levels. The Certified General license covers all types of real estate regardless of transaction value or complexity. The scope of the Residential and Certified Residential licenses is set by reference to the FDIC rule and the Appraiser Qualifications Board’s criteria. A trainee may appraise only property the supervising appraiser is qualified to appraise. Under the FDIC rule, a license alone does not make an appraiser competent: competency rests on experience and education related to the assignment.

USPAP, issued by the Appraisal Standards Board of The Appraisal Foundation, has standards for real property, personal property, business valuation and mass appraisal. The current edition is the 2024 edition, in effect since January 1, 2024; its Standards 1 to 4 cover real property appraisal development and reporting, and appraisal review. Whether an appraiser must comply depends on the laws, regulations or policies of the state, agency or client involved. State-licensed and state-certified real property appraisers must comply for federally related transactions.

For a buyer’s SBA 7(a) loan or for the IRS, who may prepare the business valuation, and how real estate bought in the same deal is appraised, are covered in Business Valuation Requirements for SBA 7(a) Loans to Buy a Business and Certified or Qualified Business Appraisers: What IRS and SBA Rules Require.

What the balance sheet and the tax bill show instead

Under US accounting standards, project costs are capitalized as a cost of the project. Project costs are the costs clearly associated with acquiring, developing and constructing a real estate project (paragraph 970-360-25-2 of the FASB Codification, as amended by Accounting Standards Update 2020-10). A figure built that way records what was spent; it is not an opinion of what the land or project would sell for.

Income tax works on cost too. Under the uniform capitalization rules, a business that produces real property, which includes constructing, developing or improving it, must include the direct costs and part of the indirect costs in the property’s basis instead of deducting them. It recovers them through depreciation, amortization or cost of goods sold when it uses or sells the property. The exceptions include a small business taxpayer that meets the gross receipts test under section 448(c) and is not a tax shelter.

The property tax roll works differently again: Proposition 13 converted California’s property tax from a market value-based system to an acquisition value-based one. The assessed value of most property taxed under Proposition 13 is the prior year’s assessed value adjusted for inflation of up to 2 percent. After a change in ownership or completed new construction, the new assessed value is the property’s market value as of that date.

Property tax after a change of control, and SBA eligibility

The State Board of Equalization runs a Legal Entity Ownership Program with the Franchise Tax Board to find changes in ownership and control of legal entities. When it determines that an entity owning California real property has undergone one, it tells the county assessors to reappraise the real property that entity owns. After a change in ownership, a supplemental assessment covers the part of the fiscal year that remains after the date of the change.

SBA-guaranteed loans are not open to every development business. Under SBA’s loan procedures, businesses primarily engaged in subdividing real property into lots and developing it for resale on their own account are not eligible. Nor are businesses primarily engaged in owning or buying real estate and leasing it. Building homes for future sale counts as speculative and is not eligible, except under SBA’s 7(a) Builders CAPLines program.

A file for each parcel: deeds, sales, leases and agreements

IRM 4.48.6 lists what the IRS’s real property appraisers obtain for each property; it is a useful list to prepare for each parcel and project:

  • The legal description and location, the land’s physical features, dimensions and access, its zoning and permitted uses, and its assessment and tax data.
  • Deeds, plat maps, blueprints and surveys where available, and any water, mineral or other rights, easements and rights-of-way.
  • Every sale of the property in the five years before the valuation date, with dates, prices, mortgage amounts and the names of sellers, buyers and lenders.
  • The cost, date and manner of acquisition, and any earlier appraisals with their dates.
  • For property that is rented: lease dates and terms, the leases themselves, rent rolls and the history of income and expenses.
  • Any agreement, signed or expected, on the property’s use or sale.

Frequently asked questions

Can our business valuer also appraise the company’s land for a bank loan?

Only with an active BREA license, if the loan is a federally related transaction: no one may engage in federally related real estate appraisal activity without one, and only a licensee may sign the appraisal. For a bank the FDIC regulates, a loan secured by real property needs an appraisal by a state certified or licensed appraiser unless one of the rule’s listed exceptions applies.

Why does our balance sheet show a different figure for the land than an appraisal?

Under US accounting standards, the balance sheet capitalizes the costs clearly associated with acquiring, developing and constructing each project. The IRS’s guidelines for its real property appraisers instead name approaches to an opinion of value such as comparable sales, reproduction or replacement cost less depreciation plus land value, and projected income.

Will selling shares in the company change its property tax?

It can. When the State Board of Equalization determines that an entity owning California real property has undergone a change in control or ownership, it tells the county assessors to reappraise that property. A change in ownership resets the assessed value to market value as of that date.

How can I check an appraiser’s California license?

BREA’s licensing FAQ points to its Find An Appraiser page for California licensees. Only licensees at a certified level may use the term “state certified real estate appraiser” in their real property appraisal business.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.

Prefer to talk first? Book a free discovery call with Andrew Mackson or Ryan Maguire, partners at Los Angeles Business Valuations.