Recalls, CARB Orders and Valuing an Automotive Parts Maker

If your company makes parts or equipment for motor vehicles, two sets of rules can attach to its products. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) sets who reports and remedies a safety defect in parts already shipped, and what a parts maker reports even without a recall. The California Air Resources Board (CARB) sets whether an add-on or modified part may be sold for use in California vehicles. Below: those duties, what the sources say and do not say about a sale of the company, and where they enter a valuation.

Original or replacement equipment: who answers for a defect

NHTSA’s defect rules, in 49 CFR Part 573, apply to makers of original and replacement equipment, for all equipment that has left the manufacturer’s direct control. Original equipment is an item (other than a tire) installed in or on a vehicle when it was delivered to its first purchaser, if it was already installed when the vehicle went to a dealer or distributor, or was installed by the dealer or distributor with the vehicle manufacturer’s express authorization. Replacement equipment is all other motor vehicle equipment, and tires.

The vehicle manufacturer is responsible for any safety-related defect, or noncompliance with a federal safety standard, in the vehicle or in any item of its original equipment; the maker of replacement equipment is responsible for any such defect or noncompliance in that equipment (49 CFR 573.5). For original equipment, the reporting depends on who uses the part: if it goes into only one vehicle manufacturer’s vehicles, the defect and quarterly reports filed by either of them count for both; if it goes into more than one manufacturer’s vehicles, the parts maker must file the defect report for the part itself. So the split between original and replacement sales, and how many vehicle manufacturers take each part, decide where these duties fall.

What a safety defect sets off

Once the manufacturer, or NHTSA, determines that a defect is related to motor vehicle safety, or that an item does not comply with a safety standard, the manufacturer must report it to NHTSA within 5 working days (49 CFR 573.6). For equipment, the report counts the items that may be affected and describes the remedy, with a plan to reimburse owners or purchasers who paid for one within a reasonable time before notification. A campaign then brings quarterly reports for six consecutive quarters, or until corrective action is complete on all the vehicles or replacement equipment involved, if sooner. The equipment maker (tires aside) keeps, for 5 years, a list of who received the items, how many and when (49 CFR 573.8).

Under 49 CFR 573.12, no one may sell or lease a new or used item of equipment for installation on a vehicle once it is the subject of a decision or a required notice under 49 U.S.C. 30118, in a condition in which it may reasonably be used for its original purpose. The exceptions are a defect or noncompliance remedied before delivery, and an order requiring notification whose enforcement a court has restrained or which it has set aside. The rule applies to all persons, not only manufacturers, and a change of owner is not among its exceptions.

Reports owed to NHTSA when nothing is recalled

49 CFR Part 579 asks makers of vehicles and equipment for information that may help identify defects:

  • Communications about defects. A copy of each notice, bulletin or other communication sent to more than one manufacturer, distributor, dealer, owner or purchaser in the United States about any defect in the company’s equipment, safety-related or not, due within five working days after the end of the month it was issued.
  • Early warning reports. Makers of original equipment, and of replacement equipment other than tires and child restraint systems, report each incident involving one or more deaths in the United States that is identified in a claim against the company, or in a notice alleging or proving that a possible defect in its equipment caused the death. The report covers equipment made or sold in the current calendar year and the four before, and is due within 60 days after each calendar quarter ends; a quarter with no such claim or notice needs no report.

A “claim” is broad: a written request or demand for relief related to a crash, an accident or a component failure, with or without a lawsuit, whether or not it was denied. In Part 579, “manufacturer” also includes any parent corporation, subsidiary or affiliate, so a corporation that acquires the company and becomes its parent corporation falls within the term. That is a definition, not a rule about sales: none of the NHTSA rules opened for this article says what a buyer takes on for parts the company shipped before the sale.

Manufacturer identification, and a change of owner

If the company makes equipment (other than tires) to which a federal motor vehicle safety standard applies, 49 CFR Part 566 requires it to file with NHTSA its full name, its address and state of incorporation, and a description of each type of equipment it makes; a general description, such as “brake fluid”, is enough. A person who begins to manufacture such equipment without having filed must file within 30 days of starting; a manufacturer on file must submit revised information within 30 days after relevant changes in its business. A buyer that carries on production through a new company that has not filed is in the first case; a company that stays on file but changes its name or address is in the second.

California: emissions-related parts sold under a CARB Executive Order

Makers of add-on and modified parts who plan to sell, offer for sale or advertise them for use in California vehicles should apply to CARB for an exemption from Vehicle Code section 27156 (CARB: Manufacturers of Aftermarket Parts). It is granted if the part is determined not to cause any increase in vehicle emissions, as an Executive Order (EO) stating that the part is legal for sale and use in California; each EO has a number that Smog Check stations or CARB can verify.

CARB’s Procedures for Exemption of Add-On and Modified Parts, adopted June 29, 2021, set these requirements:

  • Each part sold under the EO comes with a product information label showing the product name as listed on the EO, the EO number in the form “CARB D-XXX”, and the manufacturer’s name and contact information.
  • The manufacturer may not market the part under any identification other than the one on the EO, market it for an application the EO does not list, or apply the EO to parts sold before the date shown on it.
  • CARB may buy up to five new exempted parts or kits per manufacturer each year for audit testing, and must revoke an exemption if, with the part installed, the test vehicle fails to show emissions compliance, the testing reveals evidence of a defeat device, or the results otherwise fail its criteria. Breaking any condition of the procedures is also grounds for revocation, which needs 10 days’ written notice and, if the holder asks in writing, a hearing first.

Under the procedures’ rule for private labels and subsidiaries, extending an EO to another manufacturer or to the holder’s own subsidiaries needs CARB’s approval, and “the manufacturer with design control maintains all responsibility for emissions compliance.” The CARB pages and procedures opened for this article do not say what happens to an EO when the company holding it, or its business, is sold. Ask CARB how your sale affects your EOs before the price assumes they carry over.

Recall costs, open claims and Executive Order revenue in a valuation

The IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines, written for its own appraisers, say the asset-based, market and income approaches should all be considered, and historical financial statements adjusted if necessary to reflect the appropriate asset value, income and cash flows. Revenue Ruling 59-60, the IRS ruling on valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax, is reproduced in Appendix A of an IRS job aid for its valuation analysts. Three of its points meet the rules above:

  • Recall costs in the earnings record. Profit-and-loss statements, preferably for five or more years, should let the appraiser separate recurrent from nonrecurring items of income and expense. Show each recall’s remedy and reimbursement costs by year so that judgment can be made.
  • Open campaigns and claims beside the balance sheet. Balance sheet items that cover diverse assets or liabilities should be clarified in supporting schedules. List open recall campaigns, the claims and notices received, and recalled stock on hand, apart from stock that can be sold.
  • Revenue that rests on an EO. Uncertainty as to the stability or continuity of future income decreases value by increasing the risk of loss. Where sales of an add-on or modified part for California vehicles rest on an EO, which can be revoked, show which revenue depends on which EO.

The general valuation factors for a manufacturer, its machinery and inventory, and the plant permits a buyer may have to file for again are covered in Manufacturing Business Valuation: A Guide for Owners.

Industry code 336 and an SBA lender’s environmental check

Code 336, transportation equipment manufacturing, is on the SBA’s list of environmentally sensitive industries without the “assembly only” exception that codes 332 to 335 have; the list is Appendix 6 of the SBA’s Standard Operating Procedure 50 10. If your buyer uses an SBA 7(a) or 504 loan secured by commercial property, Manufacturing Business Valuation: A Guide for Owners explains what a match with that list means for the lender’s environmental investigation. The general SBA and IRS valuation rules are in Business Valuation Requirements for SBA 7(a) Loans to Buy a Business and Certified or Qualified Business Appraisers: What IRS and SBA Rules Require.

Recall, NHTSA and CARB paperwork to assemble

  • Sales by product line, split between original equipment (and how many vehicle manufacturers take it) and replacement equipment.
  • Defect and quarterly reports filed with NHTSA, and the purchaser lists for each campaign still within its 5 years.
  • Copies of defect communications sent to NHTSA, and early warning reports with the claims and notices behind them.
  • The company’s manufacturer identification entry, if it makes equipment subject to a federal safety standard.
  • Each CARB Executive Order with its number, date and the parts and vehicles it covers, and a sample product label.
  • Recall remedy and reimbursement costs by year, and a count of recalled stock on hand.

Frequently asked questions

My company only supplies parts to vehicle manufacturers. Do NHTSA’s defect rules reach it?

Yes. Part 573 applies to makers of original equipment. The vehicle manufacturer is responsible for safety-related defects in the original equipment of its vehicles; if your part goes into only one manufacturer’s vehicles, a defect report filed by either of you counts for both, and if it goes into more than one manufacturer’s vehicles, your company must file the defect report for the part itself.

Can recalled parts in my warehouse be sold after the business changes hands?

Not for installation on a vehicle while they may reasonably be used for their original purpose, unless remedied before delivery or a court has restrained or set aside the order requiring notification. The prohibition applies to all persons, and a change of owner is not among its exceptions.

Does a CARB Executive Order pass to the buyer of my company?

The CARB pages and procedures opened for this article do not say. In their rule for private labels and subsidiaries, they do say that extending an EO to another manufacturer needs CARB’s approval, and that the manufacturer with design control keeps all responsibility for emissions compliance.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.