GMV and Take Rate: Revenue Under ASC 606 and SEC Guidance

Under ASC 606, the US revenue standard, a marketplace reports the gross amount of a sale as revenue only for goods or services it controls before the buyer gets them; it is then the principal. Where it arranges for a seller to provide them, it is an agent, and its revenue is its fee or commission. Gross merchandise value (GMV) and take rate are not terms of the standard but metrics each company defines. A company that reports such a metric in the management’s discussion and analysis of its SEC filings is generally expected to say how it is defined and calculated, why it is useful and how management uses it.

Gross or net: who controls the goods before the buyer gets them

When another party is involved in providing goods or services to a customer, ASC 606 asks what you promised. If it is to provide them yourself, you are the principal; if it is to arrange for the other party to provide them, you are an agent. FASB’s 2016 update on principal versus agent considerations sets out two steps:

  1. Identify each specified good or service to be provided to the customer: a distinct good or service, or a distinct bundle of them.
  2. Assess whether you control each one before it is transferred to the customer.

If you control it, you are the principal and recognize revenue at the gross amount you expect to be entitled to. If not, you are an agent and recognize your fee or commission. That fee might be the net amount you keep after paying the other party what the customer paid for its goods or services. Holding legal title to a good only momentarily before it passes to the customer does not necessarily mean you control it.

The standard lists indicators that you control a specified good or service before the customer receives it:

  • Fulfillment. You are primarily responsible for providing it, which typically includes responsibility for its acceptability.
  • Inventory risk. You carry inventory risk before it is transferred, or after transfer, for example where the customer has a right of return.
  • Price. You have discretion in establishing the price the customer pays, although an agent can have some discretion over prices too.

The indicators support the assessment of control; how relevant or persuasive each one is depends on the facts and circumstances. Because the answer is reached for each specified good or service, one contract can make you a principal for some and an agent for others. Revenue is measured from the transaction price, which excludes amounts collected on behalf of third parties.

FASB’s marketplace example, and a contract with both answers

FASB illustrates the agent case with a website:

  • customers buy goods from a range of suppliers, who deliver the goods directly to them;
  • under its contracts with the suppliers, the operator is entitled to a commission equal to 10 percent of the sales price;
  • the suppliers set the prices, and the website facilitates payment between supplier and customer;
  • the operator has no further obligations to the customer once it has arranged for the products to be provided.

FASB calls this website a marketplace and concludes that the operator does not control the goods: at no time can it direct them to anyone other than the customer or stop the supplier from delivering them. The indicators point the same way: the supplier fulfills, the operator takes no inventory risk, and the supplier sets the price. The operator is an agent and recognizes revenue in the amount of its commission. Its revenue from each sale is therefore 10 percent of the sales price, not the whole price the customer pays.

A second example gives both answers in one contract. A recruitment services firm interviews candidates itself, and also arranges a license to a third party’s database, which the customer contracts for directly at a price the database provider sets. Treating the database access and the recruitment services as distinct, FASB concludes that the firm is an agent for the database access and the principal for the services it performs itself. If your platform also sells services it performs itself, each one gets its own answer. For valuation methods when the marketplace is also a software business, see SaaS-Enabled Marketplaces: Money Transmission and Revenue.

Credits and discounts for buyers: a question FASB is settling

Cash you pay a customer, and credits such as a coupon or voucher that can be applied against what the customer owes, are consideration payable to a customer. They reduce the transaction price and therefore revenue, unless they pay for a distinct good or service the customer transfers to you. The same applies to payments to parties that buy your goods or services from your customer.

Stakeholders told FASB the question arises frequently in platform businesses that give credits, rebates or discounts directly to end users while their contractual customer is the merchant or seller. The standard does not explicitly address when payments to a customer of your customer who is outside the direct distribution chain count as consideration payable. Stakeholders report that economically similar payments may be accounted for differently, either as a reduction of revenue or as an expense.

On October 22, 2026 FASB published a proposed update. Such a payment, made in connection with satisfying your promise to your own customer, would count as consideration payable to a customer in two cases:

  • you have explicitly promised to make it;
  • your customer reasonably expects it, because of an implicit promise or because it is in substance a price concession.

FASB’s example is a platform acting as an agent for a percentage of each order, which promises sellers a $10 credit for buyers making a first purchase from them. The platform’s customers are the sellers, not the buyers, and the credits would be consideration payable to a customer. The proposal is not final: comments close on November 23, 2026, and the effective date is still to be set. Until the rule is settled, two platforms with the same GMV and the same buyer credits can report different revenue, and different take rates if those are computed from revenue.

What the revenue note should tell a buyer

The revenue standard’s disclosures include a description of the goods or services you promised, highlighting any obligations to arrange for another party to provide them, that is, where you act as an agent. They also include the judgments, and changes in judgments, that significantly affect the amount and timing of revenue.

Read that note before comparing your revenue or take rate with another marketplace’s. In FASB’s 2024 review of the revenue standard, investors said it can be difficult to understand the judgments of seemingly similar companies, especially when they reach different principal-or-agent conclusions.

Reporting GMV or a take rate to investors: what the SEC expects

The SEC’s guidance on key performance indicators and metrics has been effective since February 25, 2020. It covers the management’s discussion and analysis (MD&A) under Item 303 of Regulation S-K, Item 5 of Form 20-F and Item 9 of Form 1-A. Smaller reporting companies and issuers relying on Regulation A are among those it says should consider it. Based on the facts and circumstances, the SEC would generally expect a metric to come with:

  • a clear definition of the metric and how it is calculated;
  • a statement of why it provides useful information to investors;
  • a statement of how management uses it in managing or monitoring the business.

For GMV, that means stating what the total includes; for a take rate, which figure is divided by which. If the company changes how a metric is calculated or presented, it should consider disclosing, to the extent material, the differences, the reasons and the effects.

Where a figure is a non-GAAP financial measure, Regulation G applies to registrants: companies with securities registered under Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, or required to file reports under its Section 15(d), other than registered investment companies. A registrant that publicly discloses material information including such a measure must, with limited exceptions, present the most directly comparable GAAP measure and a reconciliation, and must not make the measure public in a misleading way. Two of the SEC staff’s interpretations on non-GAAP measures, last updated December 13, 2022, bear directly on marketplaces:

  • a non-GAAP measure of revenue presented on a gross basis when GAAP requires net presentation, or the inverse, is among the examples the staff may consider misleading;
  • a non-GAAP measure labeled the same as a GAAP line item, such as “Sales”, but calculated differently would violate Regulation G’s rule against misleading measures.

So if your revenue is reported net, do not label a total of transactions as revenue or sales.

Figures to prepare before a marketplace is valued

Before a valuation, prepare the papers that show how GMV becomes revenue:

  • your revenue recognition policy or note, with the principal-or-agent conclusion for each good or service you provide;
  • seller terms showing who is responsible for fulfillment, who carries inventory and return risk, and who sets prices;
  • your written definitions of GMV and take rate, how each is calculated, and any change of definition with its reason and effect;
  • a schedule from GMV to revenue: amounts passed on to sellers, your fees, and credits and other payments to users;
  • how buyer credits and other incentives are accounted for, as a reduction of revenue or as an expense.

The purpose of the valuation brings rules of its own. For option grants, see 409A Valuation Rules for Stock Option Grants. For valuations used for the IRS, and who may prepare them, see Certified or Qualified Business Appraisers: What IRS and SBA Rules Require. A broader look at valuing a marketplace business is in Online Marketplaces: INFORM Consumers Act and California Law. What this means for your business depends on its own numbers and the purpose of the valuation; that is what a valuation report sets out.

Frequently asked questions

Can we show GMV as our revenue?

Only for goods or services you control before they reach the buyer; for those you are the principal and report the gross amount you expect to be entitled to. Where you arrange for sellers to provide them, your revenue is your fee or commission.

We set the prices on our platform. Does that make us the principal?

Not by itself. Price discretion is one indicator of control, alongside fulfillment and inventory risk, and an agent can have some discretion over prices too.

Do first-purchase credits we give buyers reduce our revenue?

Credits given to your own customers do, unless they pay for a distinct good or service the customer transfers to you. For buyers who are your sellers’ customers, the standard does not explicitly address when such payments count, and practice differs. FASB’s October 2026 proposal looks at such payments when they are made in connection with satisfying your promise to your seller customers. They would then be consideration payable to a customer if you promised them explicitly, or if those sellers reasonably expect them because of an implicit promise or because they are in substance a price concession. The proposal is not final.

We are a private company. Does the SEC’s guidance on metrics apply to us?

Regulation G applies only to registrants, and the 2020 guidance covers MD&A in SEC filings, including those of issuers relying on Regulation A. A company that files nothing with the SEC is outside both, but defining each metric and how it is calculated still makes its figures easier for a buyer or valuer to check.

Related reading

Valuing your own business? Los Angeles Business Valuations’ reports start from $799. See Services & Pricing or contact us. For a first estimate, try the free business valuation calculator.